I am a little shocked jasmine went home over Megan. I thought the whole Rockin Robin thing was a train wreck.

Adam is becoming over rated..
I kinda like megan ...just dont like how she moves!
Lol who disturbs you Michelle?Jorge?

Oh yes I can see Jasmine getting a record deal. But yes Jorge bothered me as well.

Darn, I missed it again!! I'll have something to say next week, when I REMEMBER to watch American Idol!

I was shocked to see Jasmine leave. But although I like Megan the Rocken Robin song was awful. Her moves she does are annoying. She does them in every song she sings. I was excited to see Jorge leave. He annoyed me too.

She does have a quirky dance. lol

I am still rooting for Alexis!! She is my favorite.

Megan does get on my nerves!I think she is gorgeous though!

Ok,well adams performance was very trippy,but I liked it,jeff was sitting here going *** ..thats horrible!
But my top 3 is kris allen,matt giuard and adam.
Oh and I liked what Lil did tonight..she COULD of went on there (like randy said)and did I will always love you and she didnt and thats respectable to me...she didnt want to make it an R&B song,that would of been predictable.I bet if she did the judges would of friggin said that!They get on my flippin nerves and Paula is such an air head,I swear she gets worse and worse everytime I watch it.

I loved Matt, Anoop, and Danny....though Danny was my least favorite of the three...

Alexis I like but this week I didn't think she was as good as she can be.

James favorite is Megan...I thought it looked like she had oranges in her dress....but I thought she did an amazing job for having the flu...that shows balls..

Adam...ruined Ring of Fire for me I'm a huge Johnny Cash fan.....I think he rolled over in his grave!

Paula is on medication...pain killers for a pretty serious condition she has....we were reading up on it at work last week...though I have to say me and my friend make fun of her all the time...cause she just gets so goofy on them....she just makes me laugh with some of the things she says and does!

Oh no,I forgot Noop dawg!I love him.
Michelle,I agree about adam..its an awesome song he didnt have to change it,but it was deffantly different and thats what he is going for.

quote:

Adam...ruined Ring of Fire for me I'm a huge Johnny Cash fan.....I think he rolled over in his grave!

YES Chelle, that performance was horrible. It's a good thing Johnny couldn't hear that cr*p. I'm also a huge fan.

Flu or no flu, can't stand Meghan and how she sings or moves.

Anoop really did a great job.

As for Danny....boy is he cute and I hope he stays on,love that man.

Ok for me Danny was just super great.


What was Adam thinking

Megaen I think could be going home

Anoop was great what a way to come back

Lil was good coupld have been better. She played it safe.

Here is my take on AI last night.

Danny was good
Alexis was good
as for Adam he was awful, he was not thinking when he sang that song. Although I love that song and loved Johnney Cash. I am sick of Megans movements she does when she sings. She does it with every song.

I think Megan or Michael will go

I really like Danny, Alexis and the piano man- the last one to go, I forgot his name. I didn't care for the version of ring of fire Adam used either, but he didn't "do" anything to the song. It was an arrangement he found by someone else, he didn't arrange it

quote:

I didn't care for the version of ring of fire Adam used either, but he didn't "do" anything to the song. It was an arrangement he found by someone else, he didn't arrange it

Thank you! DH and I said the same thing...he acted like it was his arrangement and it wasn't. We've heard it before too! It wasn't new!

Loved Matt and Anoop this week. I thought Kris did really well also. Wasn't thrilled with any of the girls, they were just okay. Adam, I didn't like the version of the song he chose but he did shock me with his range again but I couldn't even focus on that because the version of the song was so bad.
I think that whole thing is risky which is why it annoyed me they told Lil she should have tried to find an R&B version of a country song. The only time that has ever really worked was David Cook's version of Billy Jean and he didn't change the genre, just the arrangement.

I just heard a woman that was on rockstar super nova..which is where I think adam got that version from...I dont think he acted like it was his...he said he FOUND another version he liked.

I can't believe Alexis went home....if they were going solely on bad performances the night before I would have though Adam would have been in the bottom...

If I had to of picked someone out of the bottom three to go it would have been Matt the oil rigger.....

I was soooo not happy with her going home. I liked her and honestly I really thought she did good the night before singing that song. I voted for her! Of course I still cant narrow it down to just one person yet so I voted for a few people but hey I did vote for her.